正观“红色”

正观“红色”

年份:1983

地区:美国

上映:

评分:0.0 分

播放:8 次

更新:2020年08月16日

导演:吉姆·克莱恩|朱莉娅·赖克特

编剧:

主演:

分类:纪录片|历史

Julia Reichert and Jim Klein (who were also responsible for UNION MAIDS - spotting a theme yet?) made this doco in 1983, fortunately in enough time to snag interviews with a number of senior citizens who were right in the thick of it way back when the communist party established itself in the U.S. SEEING RED takes us through the trials and tribulations of the party through the changes of the decades - the depression, the Spanish Civil War, World War II, the Cold War and subsequent HUAC hearings, the devastating revelations about exactly what kinda guy Stalin had become, and of course all the hardline propaganda that beleaguered them at every turn.
  Even though the film-makers' sympathies lie clearly with their interview subjects, SEEING RED isn't meant to be pro-Pinko (while even now still holding on to their ideals these old folks admit the official party line lost its way, and point out where things went wrong). Pete Seeger (of The Weavers) gets to sing a few songs; Reagan, Nixon, McCarthy and even actor John Saxon make archival appearances. If you weren't aware of the full story behind this marginalised slice of history, then here's your chance to find out.
登录后参与评论
斑驳大象

老师的老师LOL

回复 举报
宇宙尽头小卖部

3.5 历史的部分非常弱。几乎到冷战就截止了,而且历史线的叙述很凌乱,导致主线不明显。对美共的讨论,包括对“共产主义”这个概念的讨论仍然是集中体现于fordism的劳工以及对工作的需求。美国的共产主义运动兴起于大萧条,其实这群人类似于中国的下岗工人。整个纪录片对于“现象”和“观点”的描述大于对美国共产党运动的反思。同时表述仍然集中于“人权”表达,比如美国对共产党迫害。中方心思和现在美国左派的一些“人权”表达无异议。只是对象变成了“美国共产党”。总体而言有意义,采访很详尽。QA导演一直在说对美共的threat在哪,我心想有什么threat你没逼数吗?包括这部片子本身对冷战前后美苏关系也是暧昧,六十年代的中国和越南以及北朝鲜更是完全没提及……

回复 举报
藕粽

回复 举报

也许您会喜欢

  • 电影
  • 电视剧
  • 综艺
  • 动漫
  • 纪录片